When you buy a new mattress, you should take some opportunity to consider your choices carefully. This will let you locate the highest quality and cost following your requirements. According to construction, mattresses today fall into one of five general forms: all-foam mattress, innerspring, hybrid, latex, or airbed. Beds in each class generally share many similarities, but there might also be noteworthy differences between these versions.

Casper vs Tuft And Needle Mattress are top companies in the developing field of internet, direct-to-consumer mattress earnings. Even though Casper captured a huge market share by being fast to market and using prevalent marketing, Tuft and Needle were rising. Additionally, it has invested heavily in product improvement and promotion.

Within the following report, we will compare those two mattresses to help you decide which will be most appropriate for you.

Casper vs Tuft And Needle Mattress Comparison

Comparing Casper vs Tuft And Needle

Similarities between Tuft Needle vs Casper

Although Casper, Tuft and Needle are all different, there is some commonality between them.

  • Two of the most popular bed in a box mattress models are Tuft and Needle and Casper.
  • Both are all-foam mattresses and do not have coils.
  • Similar base foam layers are used in the Casper, Tuft, and Needle.
  • These mattresses have a balanced, responsive foam feel.

Differences between Tuft Needle vs Casper

Let’s now look at some of the key differences between Casper, Tuft, and Needle.

  • The Tuft and Needle mattress is more affordable than the Casper. These mattresses are priced in line with the online mattress industry, but the Casper can cost up to $400 more than the Tuft & Needle.
  • The Casper, Tuft, and Needle have different materials in their designs.
  • Casper mattress has more layers than the Tuft or Needle.
  • The Casper mattress features a zoned construction, while the Tuft & Needle mattress doesn’t.
  • There are some differences in firmness – the Tuft and Needle mattress is slightly firmer than the Casper.

Construction and Materials Comparison

How the layers are laid out and what materials are used in each layer can greatly impact the quality of any mattress.

Two elements make up the interior of a mattress: the comfort system and support core. The mattress’s support core is its bottom section. It provides the structural integrity of the whole mattress. It provides comfort and support for the mattress’s feel.

The comfort system is the top layer of the mattress. It has a significant impact on the bed’s characteristics. It may include multiple layers and materials. These layers often include foam, latex, micro-coils, and fabrics such as wool and cotton.

It is important to examine the construction of the Tuft & Needle beds and Casper beds from the comfort system through the support core to compare them truly.

Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle
Tuft & Needle

Two components are common to all Tuft & Needle mattresses. The cover is made of micro-polyamide and polyester and provides a soft and breathable surface for the Original, Mint, and Hybrid.

The second component of all Tuft & Needle mattresses is the company’s proprietary Adaptive Foam. Adaptive Foam, a polyfoam formula that offers a unique blend of foam and gel, is the company’s second component.

These are the same traits found in latex and memory foam.

Adaptive foam is a mildly conforming foam that provides pressure relief. It can also provide extra cushioning for heavier areas of the body. It is also responsive, which makes it easy to move over it. It is not like traditional memory foam and does not get softer with heat buildup.

Original Tuft & Needle

  • The Original Tuft & Needle Mattress has one of the most simple designs you will find.
  • 3 inches of Adaptive foam
  • 7 inches high-density polyfoam

Although the Original is not fancy in its construction, it provides ample support and comfort for most sleepers, particularly its medium firm feel.

Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress

Tuft & Needle, which built on the success of their Original, launched the Mint. This adds only one layer to its predecessor’s design.

  • 3 inches of Adaptive foam
  • 2 inches of Adaptive foam
  • 7 inches high-density polyfoam

The Mint mattress comfort system is 2 inches thicker, so it provides better pressure relief and longer-lasting durability for over 230 lbs. The extra-thick comfort system protects the mattress from sinking too deeply. The Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress cover contains an antimicrobial protectorant to protect the mattress from microbes, including harmful bacteria.

Tuft & Needle Hybrid

The Tuft and Needle Hybrid use a different construction approach:

  • Foam with adaptive properties
  • Micro-coils
  • Transition polyfoam
  • Innerspring coils with pockets

T&N Hybrid has comfort layers of graphite-infused, adaptive polyfoam, and micro coils. This is layered over a transitional layer of polyfoam and a core with a pocketed coil support core. Its coil-on–coil design makes the bed extremely responsive and breathable. The T&N Hybrid is medium in feel and slightly softer than the Tuft & Needle mattresses.

Although Tuft & Needle lists the materials used in their mattresses, they don’t provide specific specifications. The Hybrid’s thicknesses are not publically listed, which is a problem, especially when it comes to Hybrid. It isn’t easy to evaluate a mattress in detail, but reviews from customers can provide valuable insight into its performance.



Casper offers five types of mattresses in its product line.

The Casper original mattress and Casper Hybrid

The Casper original mattress and the Casper Hybrid, its companion mattress, have the same comfort system but a different support center.

These are the layers of Casper original mattress:

  • 1.5 inches of polyfoam
  • 2 inches of zoned Memory Foam
  • Polyfoam 7″

This is the Casper Hybrid’s construction:

  • 1.5 inches of polyfoam
  • 2 inches of zoned Memory Foam
  • 6 inches of pocketed coils in a 7-inch foam encasement

The Casper Hybrid and Casper Hybrid create significant contouring by using two types of foam in their comfort system. These mattresses provide superior pressure relief and motion isolation. Hybrids offer more bounce and edge support.

Casper Element mattress

Casper’s entry-level product is the Casper Element mattress. The Casper Element is a basic mattress that comes with the following features:

  • 3 inches of ventilated Polyfoam
  • Polyfoam 6.5 inches

The Element, like other Casper beds, provides pressure relief via the foam in the comfort layer. However, it doesn’t have the zones of foams that are found in other models. This mattress is a good value for those on a budget and was created as an entry-level, basic mattress.

Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress

These components make up the Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress.

  • 1 inch of polyfoam
  • 1.5 inches of ventilated lax
  • 1.5 inches of zoned Memory Foam
  • 1.5 inches of zoned foam with targeted gel pods
  • 6 inches of pocketed coils, with a 7-inch foam encasement

Wave Hybrid’s robust design takes full advantage of Casper’s innovative approach to product creation. The new feature is the targeted gel pods layer. These pods enhance the mattress’s ability to offer zoned support layer that can be adjusted to suit any sleeper.

A combination of pressure relief, motion isolation, bounce, and latex-like polyfoam is achieved by using memory foam, latex, and latex above the gel-pod layers.

Wave Hybrid is resistant to heat buildup and keeps the mattress cool despite its contouring. It is medium-firm and suitable for side sleepers as well as those under 130 pounds.

Casper Nova Hybrid

These components make up the Nova Hybrid:

  • 1” Adaptive Polyfoam
  • 1.5″ zoned polyfoam
  • 2″ contour-cut memory foam
  • 6” pocketed coils enclosed in a 7-inch polyfoam encasement

The Nova Hybrid, Casper’s most comfortable mattress, provides extraordinary contouring for hybrid models. The top layer of adaptive foam wraps the body tightly, while the second layer of polyfoam is divided into three firmness zones. This allows for enhanced support in the most needed areas and provides comfortable cradling for the lighter parts of the body.

The Nova Hybrid offers a steady temperature and motion isolation that is above average for couples. Anyone who likes a more luxurious mattress feel will love the Nova Hybrid.

Check also Purple vs Casper Mattress comparison: http://nousdecor.com/purple-vs-casper-mattress

How Can The Casper and Tuft & Needle Mattress Feel?

How Can The Tuft & Needle and Casper Mattresses Feel

Then let us discuss firmness levels and surface textures. We will also compare the T&N Original Mattress and Casper Mattress concerning border support, ease of motion, and fever neutrality.


The T&N Original Mattress includes a medium-firm feel, which speeds about a 6 to the 1-10 firmness scale. The mattress has a polyfoam comfort layer that shapes slightly; however, you won’t sink a lot below the surface. Instead, anticipate moderate pruning using a mild bounce.

The mattress’s balance of design and responsiveness is ideal for several back sleepers. This position necessitates added support for your waist, as our bodies tend to sag in locations where large numbers of weight are focused. The bed also provides close cushioning to the shoulders and buttocks. This produces that the T&N Original Mattress, a fantastic selection for side sleepers. After analyzing the mattress, the many favorable evaluations come from back and side sleepers who weigh 230 lbs or less.

The Casper Mattress includes a moderate (5) feel. You will encounter closer conforming with this mattress, and it is mainly due to its memory foam comfort layer. Nevertheless, the zoned transitional coating works using the high-density foam foundation to maintain the human body in an even plane.

Typically, side sleepers who weigh 230 lbs or less favor softer beds. This certainly appears to be the situation with all the Casper Mattress. Side sleepers in this weight group provide outstanding mattress ratings since the foam layers offer you ample padding for those shoulders and buttocks, ensuring spinal alignment and concentrated pressure relief.

Back sleepers who weigh less than 130 pounds additionally locate the Casper Mattress reasonably comfy and inviting. But, people who weigh greater than 230 pounds – especially back and stomach sleepers – will probably discover the mattress too soft and saggy.

Although tastes differ from sleeper to sleeper, many sleepers find moderate soft, medium, or medium firm mattresses many comfy. These firmness levels provide a balance of gentle contouring and firm support. Many beds now have moderate soft to medium-firm feels for this particular reason.


The T&N Original doesn’t feel as resilient as a mattress using a latex comfort layer or a spiral system at the service center, but it’s more responsive than the Casper Mattress.

This is a result of the poly-foam relaxation layer found from the T&N Original Mattress. Polyfoam is much more reactive than memory foam; therefore, this generates noticeable bounciness on the mattress’s surface. The Casper Mattress also has a high polyfoam coating, and you will see a light rebound. However, the memory foam coating adheres to your body to give the mattress a more balanced and adapting feel.

As soon as we talk about the responsiveness of a mattress, we are talking about how fast the surface reacts to your body, in addition to how quickly it melts after exposure to pressure. Quite responsive mattresses will respond fast, producing noticeable springiness. Less responsive models react gradually, and you’re going to encounter a more slow sink.

Along with the surface texture, responsiveness can affect how mattresses feel during sexual activity. Many couples also favor bouncier beds for gender, particularly if they often change positions. Softer beds that shape may sag too significantly during sexual activity, resulting in distress and hinder motion.

Edge Support and Ease of Movement

Edge support identifies the substances which reinforce the outside of the mattress. Beds with powerful perimeter support will not sink too much once you get in and out of bed, and you ought to feel relatively safe sleeping near the borders. Models with poorer support will sink more and probably feel much less secure if you would rather sleep near the edge of your mattress.

Even with a more responsive feel, the T&N Original Mattress lacks powerful edge support and can be exposed to sinkage across the perimeter. You will notice some sagging once you get in and out of bed, and also, the shaky perimeter might cause feelings of roll-off should you sleep too near the borders. The Casper Mattress can be somewhat weak regarding border support.

Edge support is connected with ease of motion throughout the face of a mattress. Beds that sink across the perimeter can restrict you and your sleeping partner to the center of the mattress since the borders feel less secure.

Additionally, this may move harder during intercourse. The T&N Original Mattress provides excellent ease of motion since the polyfoam layers are quite responsive, whereas going round the Casper Mattress is harder because of the deep contouring.

Edge support and ease of motion are typical flaws for all-foam mattresses. High-density polyfoam provides adequate general equilibrium, but the substance can’t withstand compression in addition to coils or latex. As time passes, you will probably detect deeper sinking across the borders of your all-foam mattress. This will make getting in, and out of bed quite tricky since the mattress nears the end of its lifespan.

Read also: Best Mattress Brand 2024: Top Brands Review


Some beds are created with ventilated latex, open coil systems, along with other elements that promote airflow across the inside. This also aids the mattress in keeping a relaxed, comfortable temperature. Other beds absorb and trap heat close to the surface, resulting in excessive heat for sleepers. All-foam beds are renowned for sleeping hot – but thankfully, the T&N Original Mattress and Casper Mattress are noteworthy exceptions.

The T&N Original Mattress includes a comfortable layer made from open-cell polyfoam. Compared to milder foams used in different mattresses, open-cell polyfoam is quite breathable and doesn’t trap much body heat. The mattress’s comfort layer can be infused with graphite, which is meant to promote heat. If you generally sleep hot on all-foam beds, then the T&N Original Mattress will probably be a refreshing change of pace.

The same is true for your Casper Mattress. Its relaxation levels of open-cell polyfoam and medium-density memory foam can trap some heat, but many sleepers locate the mattress pretty cool. It is worth noting the Casper Mattress is rather soft, which means that you sink marginally deeply.

Consequently, those who weigh greater than 230 pounds will probably sleep hotter than many others since the foam will shape more tightly to their bodies, limiting surface airflow during the process. The T&N Original Mattress includes a firmer sense, and that means you will experience more airflow since the foam retains the human body in an even plane close to the surface.

However, if you typically sleep too hot, you could come across both these mattresses as overly hot. We advocate an innerspring or hybrid vehicle using a coil system for hot sleepers since these beds typically sleep the trendiest because of their powerful internal airflow. Most mattresses with latex coatings also provide quite a good temperature neutrality.


If you would like a mattress that works nicely for sexual action, start looking for an alternative with loads of responsiveness. When you proceed to a receptive mattress, it seems resilient, making it effortless to move on the mattress rapidly.

Latex and hybrid mattresses usually have maximum responsiveness. By comparison, plush mattresses which gradually rebound when stress is eliminated can complicate sexual activity by inhibiting motion.

Pressure relief

Mattresses for Side sleepers need pressure relief. You’re more likely to feel stiffness or soreness if you don’t have pressure relief. Casper mattress provides more pressure relief, in our view.

The memory foam layer near the foot and head of the mattress are softer, which allows for additional sinkage around pressure points.

Although the Tuft and Needle mattress does not provide as much pressure relief, it is sufficient for light stomach sleepers and back sleepers of average weight.


Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) generated during the production process can emanate out of a mattress if it’s first installed in your bedroom. This is not a health hazard, but it might result in a noticeable odor. This odor, which generally is worse using foam mattresses, usually goes away in a couple of hours. Still, to folks that are extremely sensitive to odor, it might persist and be very bothersome.

Sleeping Hot Or Cold

The Casper and Tuft and Needle are all-foam mattresses, which means they are not as breathable as innerspring or hybrid mattresses. Both mattresses have cooling features such as AirScape technology, gel, and graphite infusions.

One of the best innerspring mattresses is for those who desire the airflow and breathability of coils.

Motion Transfer

The Casper mattress should be able to handle motion transfer better between the Tuft or Needle mattresses. The Casper mattress has memory foam in its second layer.

This material is known for being very effective at isolating movement. The Casper is an excellent choice for couples who want the best mattress.


Casper is a thicker and more complicated mattress. It should last for many years. The Tuft and Needle mattresses are simpler and will not last as long as the Casper.


The Casper, Tuft and Needle mattresses are all good mattresses for sex. Both are responsive mattresses that have a balanced foam feel. This will make it easy for partners to move about and reposition.

Designs, Sizes, and Worth

We know that price issues and are essential for any comparison. Therefore, the costs for every size of these Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses are all recorded in the table below.

Mattress Size Tuft & Needle Casper
Twin $450 $595
Twin XL $495 $695
Full $595 $995
Queen $695 $1,095
King $850 $1,295
California King $850 $1,295

As you can see from the table, the Tuft and Needle mattress are considerably less costly than the Casper. Both companies run promotions or reductions, although you’re most likely to find bigger discounts provided by Casper.

Given the proven history of this Tuft and Needle mattress, its cost point signifies a tremendous value in contrast to virtually all other foam mattresses. It’s particularly attractive as an alternative for shoppers on a small budget.

Nevertheless, the Casper remains an affordable mattress and a fantastic value relative to numerous additional foam and traditional memory foam mattresses.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery

The ease of online mattress shopping is a major factor in brands such as Tuft and Needle and Casper. This has been possible only by paying attention to logistics such as shipping, returns, warranties, and return policies.

The following sections will help you understand the basics of buying a mattress online.



Online ordering of a mattress can be done in two ways: White Glove delivery or mattress-in-a-box shipping.

Mattress-in-a-Box Shipping

The popularity of mattress-in-a-box shipping has aided the growth of online mattress sales. The process involves compressing the mattress and wrapping it in plastic before shipping it via FedEx Ground or UPS. Once the box has been delivered to your home, you can bring the mattress to your bedroom to decompress it.

This is the most common shipping method for online mattresses. It almost always comes free. The package usually arrives within a few days of the order being placed. It is convenient, but customers should know that the package usually needs two people to be moved and set up.

Tuft and Needle offer mattress-in-a-box shipping for all its mattresses. For an additional fee, expedited mattress-in-a-box shipping can be arranged.

Casper offers standard shipping free of charge for all Casper original, Hybrid, and Element mattresses. Some locations offer expedited shipping for an additional fee, which includes same-day delivery. Wave Hybrids come with White Glove Delivery included for no additional charge.

White-Glove Delivery

White-Glove delivery includes mattress assembly. The team will bring the mattress to you and set it up in your bedroom. The service typically includes the removal of your old mattress.

Casper offers free White Glove Delivery for Wave Hybrid mattresses in California king or king sizes. Wave Hybrid mattresses in various sizes and other Casper mattresses are eligible for this service for an additional fee.

Tuft & Needle offers White Glove Delivery Services for an additional charge.

Shipping outside the Contiguous United States

The shipping policies for Alaska, Hawaii, and other destinations outside of the 48 contiguous US states are usually different. There may not be delivery available, and some options, such as White Glove delivery, may not be possible. Additional charges are often required.

Casper and Tuft & Needle offer ground delivery, but not White Glove delivery to Alaska and Hawaii. There is an additional charge at checkout. This can vary depending on your shipping address.



Online mattress sellers generally have a more flexible return policy than brick-and-mortar stores. These return policies are often referred to as a sleep trial. They allow you to test the mattress and then give you a full refund.

Customers find that a trial sleep is more valuable than visiting a showroom to try a mattress. Online companies are known for making the return process easy.

Both the Casper and Tuft & Needle offer hassle-free returns policies. You can try the mattress for 100 nights. There is no minimum time you have to keep it. These companies will work with you to arrange pickup or donation of your mattress. There is no shipping fee or return shipping.


Most mattresses come with a warranty as part of the purchase price. The warranty covers defects in workmanship and materials.

Most mattress warranties do not cover accidental or normal wear and tear. They protect against the product’s abnormal or extreme breakdown. The warranty also requires that the mattress be used only on specific types of beds frames.

A warranty will provide a remedy in the event of a defect. This usually means that the warranty allows the company to choose whether to replace or repair a defective mattress. The customer must pay a portion of the repair or replacement cost. The customer’s share will increase based on the length of time they have owned the mattress. Non-prorated warranties maintain the same coverage for the entire warranty term.

Both the Casper and Tuft & Needle include a customer-friendly warranty. This non-prorated warranty lasts 10 years and protects customers in the unlikely event of a mattress defect.

Comparison of Other Models From Tuft & Needle mattress and Casper

Comparison of Other Models From Tuft & Needle and Casper (1)

As I said, these brands also make Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses. Below I will briefly discuss a few other beds from each company’s portfolio.

Casper Element

Casper’s simplest design, the Element, has only two layers of foam.

The Original’s Zoned Support is not included in the mattress, so the bed feels firmer and more suitable for combo or back sleepers.

It’s also less expensive than other Casper mattresses in terms of price.

Casper Wave Hybrid

The Casper Wave Hybrid, which is almost identical to the Element in all aspects, is a luxurious, plush mattress that uses a combination of foam and coil layers.

Its combination of gentle materials makes this an excellent mattress for side sleepers.

The Wave Hybrid is Casper’s best choice for heavy people, as well.

Tuft & Needle Mint

The Mint is essentially a modified version of the original Tuft & Needle. It has a transition layer that adds a little more softness.

The bed is softer than the original and scores a 6/10 on the firmness scale.

Side sleepers would benefit from it.

Tuft & Needle Hybrid

To provide additional support and bounce, the Tuft & Needle hybrid includes a pocketed coil support section.

Combination sleepers may appreciate its springy feeling.

The Hybrid mattress is true medium-firm.

Who should choose The Casper?

  • People who are larger and require a supportive mattress
  • Combination sleepers or those who shift positions at night
  • For those who desire a higher-end, more advanced mattress with additional features

Who should choose the Tuft and Needle?

  • For those who want a more affordable mattress and of higher quality
  • Parents who require a mattress to sleep on with their teenager or child
  • Adults who are lighter than average don’t need as much support.

Frequently Asked Questions

Could I purchase both Casper or Tuft and Needle mattresses at a local mattress store?

A local mattress store
A local mattress store

No. Should you happen to live close to one of the few show chambers, you can visit one of these. On the other hand, the companies pride themselves on cutting out the middleman to provide as low a cost as possible.

How long after purchasing could I expect my mattress to get there?

Casper includes a delivery period of about two – 7 business days. Tuft and Needle provide a similar shipping time frame of two to five business days. Both companies warn that in which you reside, ordering by a third party and the time/day you purchase can positively or negatively impact shipping times.

How are the mattresses sent?

The two companies send their beds at a compressed roll interior a relatively compact box. Both are put up by setting the mattress where you would like it and carefully removing the vacuum package seal. The mattresses will unroll and gradually come into their normal state.

How Does ordering from Amazon impact my return policy?

In both situations, returns through Amazon are in part dictated by Amazon’s return policies. The 100-day trial remains admired, but the way the return is approved and processed will change based on if the mattress was bought directly or not.

What about bed frames and accessories?

Casper delivers a line of sheets, pillows, and bed frame and service on their site for extra fees. However, Tuft and Needle don’t fabricate any accessories but provide recommendations about what works best with their mattress. Both mattresses may go on nearly any bed frame of the same size as the mattress, and the two encourage being in an adjustable bed frame.


In a game between two quite capable brands, it’s quite hard to think of a transparent winner. The Casper mattress is better for large people, couples, or those who need a more advanced mattress. The Tuft and Needle, on the other hand, is better for light sleepers and those who are willing to spend less on a mattress.

The Casper has a Zoned Support system, which is designed to provide support and comfort for all three sleeping positions. Casper was voted one of the top bed in a box mattresses.

We hope you have found this Tuft & Needle Vs. Casper Mattress comparison is helpful for you to find a new mattress.


Similar Posts